Moonlight (2016) (Barry Jenkins)
Best Picture winner at the recent 2017 Oscars. Good performances that say a lot without the use of words. There's a restraint reminiscent of European cinema. The more I think about Moonlight, the more it grows on me. I don’t mind what color the actors are, as long as there’s a quality story, and thankfully there is. Nothing was especially new in Moonlight, yet you can empathize with the main character’s struggles. You might argue the film is too manipulative in encouraging us to feel pity for Chiron.
It’s debatable if the main character was too elusive, but could also be acknowledged as a strength by allowing the audience to contemplate their own injustice through a thinly-defined boy. And of course Chiron is written as a withdrawn character on the page.
Spoilers occur. The scenes between Chiron and Kevin are memorable, especially their encounter by the beach, the fight, and the reunion at the diner. A quality the film has is letting the supporting characters have layers. You can be a drug dealer(Juan) or a drug user(the mother), yet that is not all you amount to. I wasn’t bothered by the big changes Chiron undergoes, but it could be problematic for some viewers that the three actors look quite different physically. The poster reflects his growth and changing face.
I like what Courtney at On The Screen Reviews said in her review about “fears of acceptance and love continue to hold us back”.
Moonlight’s messages about tolerance of difference, acceptance of yourself, and the need for compassion towards the marginalized are important. Not just because of Trump's recent intolerance towards foreigners, but always.
The third act is the most captivating and André Holland as the adult Kevin delivered my favorite performance in the film, he made Chiron feel comfortable. It’s interesting the adult Chiron takes on the persona of Juan whom he met as a child. Could be because he perceives Juan as a hero/father-figure, yet in the back of his mind he must realize the consequences of drug-taking due to his mother’s addiction. An odd choice of job given his past, and one I struggled to come to terms with.
Some noticed similarities to Boyhood (2014) in the structure. I’ve read Jenkin’s was influenced by Taiwanese director Hou Hsiao-Hsien’s film Three Times (2005). Aspects reminded me of Boyz n The Hood (1991), especially Laurence Fishburne's character Furious Styles who had a similar scene by the beach as Juan did.
On a side note, I find it troubling that professional reviewers are apprehensive to criticize a film with a black cast which has a message of tolerance that most agree on. But you are not, intolerant, homophobe or racist for finding faults with a film.
I’ve read it’s the same issue with the female Ghostbusters, film critics are cautious about their reputation and possible accusations of misogyny. Perhaps bloggers are the ones who can review these films fairly, because there is not the same risk when you have anonymity.
Favorite quotes: “You ain’t got to love me, but you gonna know that I love you, do you hear Chiron?”
”I wasn't never worth shit. Never did anything I actually wanted to do, all I could do was what other folks thought I should do. I wasn't never myself.”
8/10
La La Land (2016) (Damien Chazelle)
Musical. Considering the Best Picture buzz, and my appreciation of Whiplash, La La Land was a disappointment.
Let's start off with the positives. Apparently Ryan Gosling spent two hours a day, six days a week learning the La La Land music by heart, so that effort deserves praise. I liked the defence of jazz, with mentions of Charlie Parker, Chick Webb and Count Basie. The dance in the stars sequence was memorable, and the City of Stars song is catchy if overused.
But the music and story was not at the level of inventiveness of the classics. Even though musicals are a rarity today, it’s still a very contemporary piece of entertainment, in wanting to be retro and pay homage. Also, I think John Legend is dull as a musician. The musical numbers felt a bit forced and added on to give an average story some color. A frivolous, artificial movie that was difficult to connect with emotionally.
A defense of the realism I've heard is that the two leads are aspiring talents and not great singers yet. That's a fair point. If they were great singers they would have been signed already.
Musicals are supposed to lift our spirits and this one unfortunately didn't do that for me. Whiplash was a better film.
5/10
New York, New York (1977) (Martin Scorsese)
Musical. Actually better than I expected. Considered second tier Scorsese, but even his weaker films are as good as a lot of top tier stuff released today.
The opening ball sequence is my favorite part of the film, which is both technically impressive, and Robert de Niro’s stalking women is amusing to watch. The marriage proposal scene is also a stand out, a very awkward moment and that’s why it’s memorable. Robert de Niro was convincing as a saxophonist, although I’m not a jazz expert. New York, New York is among the greatest songs of the 1970s and the jazz music was given enough space to make an impression.
La La Land was heavily inspired by this Scoresese film, especially two leads as creative people in love in the entertainment business. In Scorsese's film I cared about them, in La La Land I did not.
8/10
Delicatessen (1991) (Jean-Pierre Jeunet & Marc Caro)
Jean-Pierre Jeunet’s black comedy debut feature. Sweet, funny, dark and visually imaginative. You can’t tell what year the film is made, the dystopian future has a timelessness. The ”musical number” made up of rhythms and sounds in the building is pretty hilarious. Julie and Louison are a cute couple.
I never understood why the Troglodistes stayed so long, nor did I understand why the bathroom was filled with water? They should make a prequel with the main character as a circus clown.
May have been an influence on the comedy The Green Butchers, which German title is Dänische Delikatessen.
8/10
Valhalla Rising (2009) (Nicolas Winding Refn)
Beautifully shot with some very violent scenes. Remote locations, reminiscent of Aguirre the Wrath of God (1972). The story is set in 1000 AD and is about survival and faith. A difficult film to rate. Mads Mikkelsen delivers a captivating performance as the wordless one-eyed stranger, and the story has a hypnotic atmosphere. But I could see viewers becoming bored by the pacing and lack of story.
I’ve now completed Nicolas Winding Refn’s filmography and he really hasn’t made any duds. Even those that flopped at the box office (Valhalla Rising and Fear X) are interesting. I just hope he doesn’t sell out to Hollywood.
7/10
Johnny Larsen (1979) (Morten Arnfred)
Won four Danish film awards, including Best Film, Best Actor, Best Supporting Actor and Best Supporting Actress. A film about generations and making important choices. There's a nice flow to the coming of age story, which is set in the 1950s. The main character is in nearly every scene and his rebellious nature adds tension to situations. The love story is quite sweet.
It all feels very familiar and nothing especially original. If I had seen it when I was young I reckon the film would've been more impactful.
7/10
Lemonade (2016) (65 min version) (Kahlil Joseph & Beyoncé Knowles)
Rewatch
”Where do you go, when you go quiet”
”All the love I’ve been giving goes unnoticed. It’s just floating in the air”
8/10
It’s a Wonderful Life (1946) (Frank Capra)
Rewatch (Review)
10/10
The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (BBC tv-series) (1981)
Comedy/sci-fi. You know what? I’ve never read the book. At three hours and only six episodes, the tv-series was quicker than reading the novel. Began life as a radio series in 1978. A satirical, at-a-distance look on human existence and foibles. To show the absurdity of modern life, and how things that we consider of great importance are actually insignificant in the larger scheme of things. Many of the situations mirror situations, events, or institutions on Earth, but are exaggerated for comedic effect. Galactic bureaucracy is shown to be staggeringly inefficient(Episode 6). Bad poetry is depicted as painful, the planet earth is disposable as a hyperspace bypass is to be built in its path.
Wasn’t laugh out loud funny, but imaginative and witty in its own way. I like the sunglasses, those are pretty radical!
Author Douglas Adams was a convinced atheist, and the logic of why god vanished is quite clever. Very true that the lack of answer to the meaning of life is good business for publishers, because you can keep arguing on and on and never reach a result!
The story makes jokes about road work, loud concerts, and the food industry, a talking pig amusingly saying something like "it's ok to eat me". Adams pokes fun at the money-crazed culture with singer Hotblack Desiato spending a year dead "for tax reasons".
Now I know where Radiohead got the term “paranoid android”, which is how the manically depressed Marvin the robot is described. The robot is probably a parody on negative thinking and geniuses being too serious to have much fun.
Googleplex Star Thinker probably inspired the search engine Google. The Googleplex is the corporate headquarters complex of Google, Inc.
While the sets and practical effects do look slightly dated by today’s standards, I didn’t mind, as the story was the reason to watch. The sets and interludes have a certain charm. The scenes with supercomputer Deep Thought were especially memorable for the design. For an old series, I was pleasantly surprised there was an intelligent female character. I can see why it’s a celebrated cult classic because of the originality, quotable lines, and subversive commentary.
Favorite quote: “I'd far rather be happy than right any day.”
8/10
Any thoughts on these films and reviews? As always, I'd like to hear what you think in the comments.
I have seen only two of these films, sad to say. There's not a great deal to say about It's a Wonderful Life that hasn't been said a couple of million times already, so I'll focus on the other one: Delicatessen.
ReplyDeleteI. Love. Delicatessen. There's so much to see in it, so many little asides and weird jokes, so many comic moments that work for me completely. There are things that I don't really understand in it and I don't care at all because of how much of a joy that film is. It's the film that made me a Dominique Pinon fan.
@SJHoneywell: I noticed your 5/5 rating for Delicatessen and read your review. A very unique, visually driven film, almost cartoonish. Yes, many fun details, and yes, a reversal of the creepy underground beings. Dominique Pinon is memorable and not often does a small actor play the male lead, which makes it stand out.
DeleteHave you seen horror/comedy Cemetery Man (1994)? Has a similar offbeat atmosphere, I recommend you check it out for your Wednesday horror marathon, the story is a little bonkers but never a dull moment. Italian director Michele Soavi is also known for StageFright (1987) which I liked as well. It’s a more conventional horror but very claustrophobic.
Haven't seen it yet, but it Cemetery Man is on one of my horror lists, so I expect to get to it by the end of the year. Thanks for the recommendation--I was already looking forward to it but now I think I'll move it up in the queue.
Delete@SJHoneywell: I’ll look out for your review
DeleteYep LLL is overrated. It's so telling Stone and Gosling didn't perform their songs at the Oscars - they cannot sing! It was especially noticeable when John Legend was singing in the movie because his song was actually good and very catchy. Also they had no romantic chemistry at all
ReplyDelete@Sati: I prefer Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone in other roles. I agree the chemistry was lacking in LLL and I just didn’t care much. I watched New York, New York(reviewed here) which is similar and de Niro and Minnelli are easier to connect with on an emotional level.
DeleteI really need to get started with Hitchhiker's Guide to Galaxy. It has been on my to-watch-list forever!
ReplyDelete@thepunktheroy: Will keep an eye out for your Hitchhiker's Guide to Galaxy review. You should do a book/screen comparison!
DeleteI didn't see the mini-series, but I did see the '05 movie for The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy. I really enjoyed the quirkiness of it. It's pretty underrated, in my opinion. The show sounds like real fun. I can manage 6 episodes.
ReplyDeleteDidn't read the first two reviews because I'm in the process of writing my own for Moonlight and I hope to watch LLL this weekend. I'll be back after both are done.
@Wendell: I haven’t seen the 2005 movie, maybe I will. Although I feel it’s a pity to abbreviate Douglas Adams’ story into a 109 min film, I think something is lost then. Hopefully you can find the 3h BBC tv-series in the US. I borrowed it from the library on dvd.
DeleteWill look out for your thoughts on Moonlight and La La Land
I watched It's a Wonderful Life for the first time last December when my local cinema did a one-off screening. Admittedly I was dreading it a little, because I've seen so few black and white movies, but it was such an amazing experience! I think it'll turn into a yearly thing for me now :)
ReplyDelete@Allie: A Wonderful Life is very Christmassy and rewatchable, one of the best. I love it. Puts you in a good mood!
DeleteThanks for quoting me on Moonlight...I had to read that twice, because I didn't remember writing that haha. I surprisingly only saw Moonlight once, and it was back in October at the NOLA Film Festival. I've got the screener sitting on my desk at home. I need to revisit it.
ReplyDeleteI also want to revisit La La Land. My boyfriend, also a cinephile, hasn't seen it, and wants to see what the hype was about. I know we both agree it was good, but certainly not great. Not Chicago-musical status.
@Courtney: haha, I’m glad I reminded you of your own quote, which was an interesting take on the story. I have a feeling Moonlight could hold up to repeat viewings. I’m curious to check out his first feature Medicine for Melancholy which I may have watched long ago yet have no memory of. La La Land I’m only interested in revisiting the soundtrack, the story as you say was not THAT great.
DeleteOhhh Delicatessen... love that movie. I'm due for a rewatch.
ReplyDeleteI liked La La Land well enough, but I'm with you on it being overrated. I was quite pleased to see Moonlight win Best Picture instead.
Eric @ TWS: Delicatessen is a fun, quirky movie I could rewatch as well. Not many films are both sweet and macabre!
DeleteAgree La La Land is overrated. I think Gosling and Michelle Williams have better chemistry in Blue Valentine.
Great mix this - Still have to see Moonlight but will do soon. As for It's A Wonderful Life that is certainly a 10/10.
ReplyDeleteLittle favour - I have dropped the Alfie from my site title and see you have been kind enough to add me to your "Blogs I Follow" page. If you could do a little edit that would be great. Bit of a pain when you really want to change your site identity after a year - too late really!
@Alyson: Moonlight you ought to see. While it does deal with univeral themes, I should warn you it is VERY American.
DeleteYes, A Wonderful Life is...wonderful!
I’ve edited the name as requested
Glad you love Moonlight more than La La Land! I was definitely championing for it to win, so glad that it did, despite the snafu!
ReplyDelete"You might argue the film is too manipulative in encouraging us to feel pity for Chiron." I actually thought that the film was not manipulative, and that's why I admire it. It also wasn't just about a gay kid, it's an intriguing, heartfelt journey about a boy growing up to be a man, it's more about masculinity than homosexuality I think. In any case, it's a masterpiece.
It’s a Wonderful Life is indeed wonderful!!
@Ruth: I agree there’s subtlety in the performances and he isn’t just a stereotype. There is as you say heartfelt emotion, just I think the storytelling does have a tad manipulative method of making us feel pity for Chiron. I’m ok with that, as it isn’t done in a massively obvious way.
DeleteI like your interpretation that Moonlight is about masculinity. I found an article in which eight black artists, writers and speakers dissect Barry Jenkins' film: http://www.cbc.ca/arts/masculinity-and-moonlight-eight-black-men-dissect-barry-jenkins-momentous-film-1.3836460
Nice reviews! I loved Moonlight too, and felt the same way about La La Land. It was a nice movie, but it didn't quite capture the theatricality or uplifting nature of classic Hollywood. Lemonade is worth a 10000 re-watches and there's something different/new to pick up every time.
ReplyDelete@Katy Rochelle: Thank you and sorry for the belated reply, I've been unwell the past week.
DeleteI agree Lemonade can reveal new shades visually/in the voice-over on each rewatch. Her album is now in my top 10 of the year (earlier listed as top 20)
I like to my monthly round up in the same fashion as yours, but I keep to what I liked and leave out what's bad or mediocre. I simply have too little time! But your selections are a nice mix of old and new and I agree with ratings for them.
ReplyDeletehttps://cindybruchman.com/2017/02/02/are-you-not-entertained-7/
@Cindy: Yes, monthly posts are a good way to keep track. I know I say in my banner I share recommendations, but I do like to give my readers a look at every film I watched, and sometimes blog discussions arise from films I didn’t connect with. I understand that you want to prioritize for time reasons though. Glad we agree on the ratings for these.
Delete